So now, the defense. There could be significant turnover here next season. Not only with four starters being free agents, but also some depth pieces, a restricted free agent and a potential cap casualty or two perhaps?
Let’s get right to it:
Under contract: John Simon, Chase Winovich, Deatrich Wise, Derek Rivers, Nick Thurman (Futures), Tashawn Bower (Futures)
Free Agents: Keionta Davis (Restricted), Eric Lee (Practice squad)
Comments: Thin. No other way to describe it. Simon is a pretty good piece, but that is what I would describe him as…a piece. Winovich showed some promise as a strict passing down pass rushing option. But can he play on all downs? I have generally liked what I have seen from Wise in the past. But this year, every time he was on the field he seemed to commit a stupid penalty that always cost the team in a key spot. I suppose for 880k in the last year of his contract, he could be back as a depth piece. Rivers has missed a full two seasons over his three years in the league and didn’t do anything in the one he played. Perhaps it is time to move on. I bet you didn’t even know Eric Lee was back with the team this season in any capacity, did you? You may remember that he flashed for a couple of games after being signed away from the Bills’ practice squad late in 2017. Then quickly faded into obscurity and didn’t even make the 2018 team. And no, I had no idea he was here either. I would think upgrades at this position in the offseason would be in order. But the Pats never like to have a strict pass rush guy that pins his ears back and gets a ton of sacks (Chandler Jones?), so I wouldn’t expect any big names. Especially after how the Michael Bennett thing worked out this past season.
Under contract: Lawrence Guy, Byron Cowart
Free Agents: Danny Shelton, Adam Butler (Restricted)
Comments: All of a sudden Danny Shelton “matters”, eh? This guy was a healthy scratch down the stretch in 2018. A quick fall from grace for the #12 overall pick in 2015. Then he re-signed fairly late in the offseason, somewhat of an afterthought. I suppose he had a decent year, but people are now worried about losing him? Yeah, they are a little thin here as well. But still. Butler had a huge year, but it’s possible he could parlay that into big money elsewhere. For people that analyze nose tackle play, Guy supposedly had a great year. At a 5 mil cap hit next season in the last year of his contract, that probably makes him a candidate for an extension. For a guy like me that doesn’t analyze nose tackle play, I saw the team have trouble against the run this season. That tells me that the Pats could upgrade from ALL of these guys and not miss a beat. But what the hell do I know?
Under contract: Dont’a Hightower, Ja’Whaun Bentley, Terez Hall (Futures)
Free Agents: Kyle Van Noy, Jamie Collins, Elandon Roberts, Shilique Calhoun
Comments: Speaking of “thin”, this position could take a big hit this offseason. Of the four free agents that are listed above, I would say the guy most likely to return is Calhoun. But who cares about him? Someone will throw Van Noy a boatload of cash, so say goodbye to him. Collins may turn his dominant first half against bum teams into some sort of decent contract as well. And although Roberts did his job for the team and played fullback down the stretch, he made no bones about wanting to play more at LB. I imagine he will try to find a team that will let him do that. The Brady situation bears watching here as well. Hightower had a great year and got selected for the Pro Bowl. He played 15 games this year as well. But he always seems dinged up, turns 30 in March and costs 11 mil plus against the cap in the final year of his contract next year. He has been adamant in the recent past about not renegotiating his deals to lower the cap number. And is the player worth an extension under these circumstances, despite his obvious talent and leadership? My sense is that if Brady is gone and many other free agents leave, Dont’a could be a cap casualty himself as they remold the team. If Brady returns and they kind of “load up” for one more run, Hightower will most assuredly return at the same cap number as well.
Under contract: Stephon Gilmore, J.C. Jackson, Jonathan Jones, Jason McCourty, Joejuan Williams, D’Angelo Ross
Free Agents: None
Comments: Nothing to see here, though it would not shock me to see the team move on from the 5.5 mil cap hit of Jason McCourty and officially elevate Jackson to a starting position. Especially if Jason’s brother Devin does not return, but more on that later. While also creating more playing time for Williams. Then fill in the back end through the draft or low end free agency. Or maybe they can go get Duke Dawson or Keion Crossen back. Side note: congratulations to Gilmore on winning NFL Defensive Player of the Year. If you showed up against DeVante Parker of Miami in the last game of the regular season, perhaps the playoffs would have gone in a different direction. Guess the voting was already complete before that game. And no, I’m not bitter. At all.
Under contract: Patrick Chung, Duron Harmon, Terrance Brooks, Malik Gant, Obi Melifonwu (Futures), Adarius Pickett (Futures)
Free Agents: Devin McCourty
Comments: The last time Devin hit free agency, in 2015, the team told him to go out and get his contract and then come back to talk to them first before signing anything. He did and the Pats reacted by signing him to a 5 year, 47.5 million dollar contract. Seemed like a lot of dough, but hey, he was heading into his age-28 season, fully in his prime and was an invaluable member of the defense as well as the locker room. Turned out to be the right move…and by a longshot. This time around, will the Pats do the same thing? Maybe. But I don’t think he’s getting almost 10 mil per, heading into his age-33 season. Leadership or no leadership. There is a good chance he doesn’t return if he wants that money. Though, he may not get that kind of offer elsewhere. So this will be interesting to watch as well.
McCourty, Chung and Harmon have filled out a pretty solid safety crew for years now. But I am also going to question the returns of the latter two. Again, if Brady returns, they probably stick even at their almost 6 mil and 5.5 mil cap hits, respectively. But if Brady goes? All bets are off. Chung’s cocaine charges were dropped, pending good behavior or something. He was dinged up more than usual this season. And looked susceptible more than he has since his return to New England. Could he be judged expendable? If the team starts some sort of “rebuilding” process, do they also need to spend that kind of money on a third safety in Harmon? Though Harmon will be 29 as opposed to Chung, who, like McCourty, will also be heading into his age 33 season. Brooks is cheap and mostly a special teamer, so he’s safe. Just another interesting position to watch.
There you have it. A lot of words over three pieces. A lot of random thoughts. A billion questions. But not a whole helluva lot of answers.
Unfortunately, we won’t be getting pretty much any of those until mid-March…and then into the summer.
Can’t wait. But that also means winter will be almost over and that may even excite me more than Brady’s status…
Defense and specialists today…and hopefully a little shorter read…but I make no guarantees. Positive news came Saturday, most assuredly because the Blowhard wrote about it. Dwayne Allen was informed of his release. So we are off to a good start! I still will not be surprised to see him back at some point in the spring or summer once he finds out no one else wants him. Anyway, moving on…
Under contract: Keionta Davis, Derek Rivers, Deatrich Wise, Ufomba Kamalu
Unrestricted free agents: John Simon
In limbo: Trey Flowers, Adrian Clayborn
What I would do: Yikes!! Flowers is by far the best player on this list. So I would strongly consider franchise tagging him. There are very few candidates for that tag, and we’ve already ruled out using it on Trent Brown. Flowers is a great fit for this defense with his versatility and seems to be a great team guy overall.
Pickings are slim after that. Clayborn is in limbo because he counts almost 6 mil against the cap next season…and did next to nothing this past season. You most commonly found him pushed out wide and past the containment, so that the QB or RB had open field in front of them. He was a healthy scratch a few times down the stretch. We were skeptical of the signing the last offseason and we think we were proved right. Let him go and spend that money elsewhere.
Wise shows flashes, but also is banged up a lot. Davis and Rivers rarely played. Kamalu was signed late in the season and didn’t play much after that. The first three will be here, not so sure about Ufomba. I’d probably re-sign Simon for depth since he seemed to play ok when he was in there. But resources need to be invested in this position, whether it’s on Flowers or others. Adding players through the draft wouldn’t hurt either.
What the team will probably do:
Not tag Flowers and regrettably let him walk. The local writers seem to think that because Trey doesn’t post big sack numbers in this defense that he won’t command big money league-wide. But we’ve looked a few NFL free agent rankings lists from national sources and he is in the Top Ten of all free agents available. Sssssso…so much for that thinking. Not to mention the fact that the last two Defensive Coordinators the Pats have had are now at the helm of other teams. They know how good Flowers is. Seems to be a good chance they may make a run at him. Smoke is currently coming out of Miami that the Dolphins have interest. Makes sense, that is where Brian Flores just went. Flowers has rings and will likely want his dough now too…and you certainly cannot blame him for that.
Other than that? Simon will probably be back, along with Davis, Rivers and Wise. Then they will likely try to find the next Flowers in the 4th round like they did with him. Or somewhere else in the draft. Clayborn? Hard to believe he survives. But Bill does like his vets.
Under contract: Adam Butler, Lawrence Guy, Trent Harris, Frank Herron, David Parry
Unrestricted free agents: Malcom Brown, Danny Shelton
In limbo: None
What I would do: Yikes…again!! Brown and Shelton were supposed to be the big dudes in the middle that would stop the run. They couldn’t stop anyone. Yeah, I suppose some of that may have been by design…letting teams do anything they wanted to on the ground so they didn’t make big plays through the air. After all, the NFL is a passing league. But still. Those two were kind of putrid. There was probably a good reason the team passed on exercising both of their 5th year options on their rookie deals last offseason. Exercising those would have kept them both here for 2019. But would have cost them upwards of 7 million apiece. No thanks. I wouldn’t bring either of them back. Shelton was actually benched several games down the stretch. Not a good sign.
According to guys like Greg Bedard of the Boston Sports Journal, Guy was a solid player every week, sometimes spectacular. Almost worthy of team MVP consideration. I didn’t see it, but I don’t watch copious amounts of film as he does. So how the hell am I going to argue with that dude? In fact, I don’t watch any film, but that’s beside the point. In any event, as a result, we have no complaints with Guy. Butler seems useful as well. Harris, Herron and Parry seem to be practice squad types. But maybe one or more explodes in the summer and makes an impact as at least a depth piece next season.
But I’d invest a relatively high draft pick at this position (but how many picks have I given away already?). And sign another useful veteran or two with at least a little something left. Work these 2 or 3 in with Guy and Butler. Then stockpile another Harris and/or Herron and/or Perry with the real Harris, Herron and Perry for more practice squad depth.
What the team will probably do: Read recently that the Pats were considering re-signing either Brown or Shelton and perhaps both. Ugh. I don’t know about that one. But they do need bodies. And if it was partly a scheme thing where they were exposed, then…maybe. But it wouldn’t shock me if at least one was back. They would have to come significantly cheaper than the 7 mil mentioned above though. Brown is the higher rated one and the possibility exists that he has run his course in New England. Shelton maybe can use the excuse of having one year to adjust to the system. I wouldn’t buy it, but maybe Bill cuts him that slack.
I believe they do take one high in the draft too…Brown went in the first round when he came in and Vince Wilfork back a bit too. Then they just fill up with some other dudes that won’t cost much. I wouldn’t expect a big splash here.
Under contract: Elandon Roberts, Kyle Van Noy, Ja’whaun Bentley, Calvin Munson, Christian Sam
Unrestricted free agents: None
In limbo: Dont’a Hightower
What I would do: Welp, Hightower already came out and said he would not take a pay cut, so there is that. Because that is something I would certainly attempt to do. Dont’a looked rather pedestrian most of the year, until the Super Bowl at least. 11 mil against the cap in each of the next two years, seems like too much. If they end up having the room, I’d probably keep him at that number at least one more year. The reasoning is that Roberts still stinks and they really don’t know what they have in Bentley quite yet. He looked pretty good early on, but then got hurt. So we will see. Van Noy has one year left on his deal and undoubtedly will be looking for big dough. He seemed to take a step up this past year, but is that for real? I’d obviously work to try to extend him, but not if the money is extremely silly.
I’d consider bringing another veteran here as well and perhaps a draft pick. But it’s hard to tell if they need many more bodies here. Rivers and Simon could possibly be considered outside linebackers. Plus safety Patrick Chung fills some of this role. So they may not need another vet if they have all the bodies above.
What the team will probably do: I imagine they keep Hightower at his current number. For one more year anyway. I bet they try to extend Van Noy as well. I’m thinking they will lowball him though, per usual, and he won’t bite. I mean, he has two rings now and three Super Bowl appearances in his two and a half years in New England. After his age-28 season in 2019, he will want to get PAID. And that won’t happen here. Bentley and Roberts return along with the rest. They may draft someone, but I don’t actually see them doing much here.
Under contract: Stephon Gilmore, Duke Dawson, Keion Crossen, J.C. Jackson
Unrestricted free agents: Eric Rowe, Jason McCourty
In limbo: Jonathan Jones (restricted free agent)
What I would do: Tender Jones at the highest level they can, so he doesn’t get lost. Or re-sign him quickly. I know, he’s Jonathan Jones. But he has mostly acquitted himself well at slot corner when he is out there. Plus he added safety to his repertoire in the Super Bowl (and likely other games but no one noticed). And with the top three safeties getting up in age and not much depth behind them, Jones could play a key role going forward. Especially if the second round pick Dawson actually gets on the field next season. They like him still and apparently, his best position is slot corner. I’d consider re-signing McCourty as a depth piece, as long as he doesn’t command too much. The team loves Jackson, but Jason can be some insurance as they continue to bring J.C. along. It’s time to part with Rowe of course.
What the team will probably do: Exactly as I mentioned above. If Jason wants to come back, it will have to be on the cheap. Maybe the Pats gamble on Jones by not tendering him at a high level, but they also value him on special teams and you know how Bill feels about those guys. I would expect them to bring him back. They will also probably let Rowe hit the bricks, now that there are a lot of capable bodies at the position.
Under contract: Patrick Chung, Duron Harmon, Obi Melifonwu, A.J. Howard
Unrestricted free agents: None
In limbo: Devin McCourty
What I would do: McCourty has a ridiculously high cap number at thirteen and a half. That is unacceptable. He looked a step slower this year himself. But would I cut him? Hmmmmm…probably not without a capable player to replace him. Since 2019 is the last year of his deal and that he has stated that he will continue playing AND seeing that he is a good leader for this team, I would consider extending him a year or two to get that cap number down. Chung is solid and locked in. Harmon is overpaid as well, but the number doesn’t kill them and you could do worse at third safety, so he sticks. No idea if Melifonwu can add anything after a full offseason with the team. Or Howard either for that matter. I would bring another decent body in, whether that is through free agency or the draft.
What the team will probably do: I bet Devin balks at a pay cut if asked. He may extend, but since his play slipped a bit and he did talk retirement the week of the Super Bowl, the Pats may not go that route. Hard to believe they would cut him, seeing that they overpaid greatly for him once he hit free agency last time and of course what he brings to the table as far as locker room presence and leadership qualities go. I believe he just sticks at that cap number for 2019, as unseemly as that sounds, and let things play out next offseason. I do expect the team to add some bodies here, but don’t go expecting Earl Thomas or anything. If Thomas is even still any good, that is.
Under contract: Matthew Slater (ST), Nate Ebner (ST), Brandon King (ST), Joe Cardona (LS)
Unrestricted free agents: Ryan Allen (P), Ramon Humber (ST), Albert McClellan (ST)
In limbo: Stephen Gostkowski (K)
What I would do: Gostkowski is a free agent and I would definitely bring him back. Sorry. He has declined a bit but is still pretty solid. His playoff performance in recent years does kind of make me pause. BUT…who else are you going to bring in? We all have seen how bad kicking is across the NFL. It continues to mystify me how the league cannot find 32 good kickers in this entire world. It also continues to mystify me how kickers all of a sudden have a problem with the extra point, as soon as the yard line was moved back to make it a 33 yarder a few years back. I don’t know if I would use the franchise tag on Stephen, but they have used it before on him and although I may use the tag on Flowers, I know the team won’t. So they will have the option to use it on Gostkowski. Yet again though, I would bring in competition for him at camp, something they have not done in years. Maybe that helps him even more.
I’d bring back Allen, Humber and McClellan too. But the world won’t end if they don’t. And I’m not overspending to keep a punter. The Pats actually brought in a kid last year and tried to hide him by not having him punt in the preseason. Didn’t work, as Corey Bojorquez was claimed by Buffalo at final cuts. Can’t hurt to bring in another punter for competition even if they bring Allen back. But the punter is probably last on everyone’s list. McClellan seemed to make plays out there once he was signed halfway through the season. He blocked two punts in one game. But they will find other veteran special teamers if Humber and McClellan leave.
What the team will probably do: Gostkowski will be franchised…I can feel it. They will probably try to sign the other three free agents as well. But again, they will find replacements if they can’t. Not much to fret about here.
OK, so this piece wasn’t shorter, my apologies. But we are finished!
Moving right on to the defense…
Locks: Trey Flowers, Derek Rivers, Deatrich Wise
In: Adrian Clayborn
Out: Keionta Davis, Eric Lee
Way Out: Frank Herron
Comments: I’m putting Flowers in the Shaq Mason category. Trey is in the last year of his deal and may command big money next year. Money I don’t think the Pats will pay. Now, he may not command “Chandler Jones money”. He hasn’t had the start to his career that Chandler had. But he may still be too expensive for Bill’s taste. I think if a trade made sense, Bill may do it. I probably wouldn’t, as you can see the depth is a little thin at this position. But I’m not ruling out the possibility.
Hopefully Wise can build on a decent rookie year and that Rivers can show something after missing last year due to injury. Clayborn is probably a lock due to the contract…a surprising one at that…with like 2/3 of his sacks coming in a single game last year. But again, every year there is a long-time veteran that just doesn’t fit in the Patriots’ system. For some reason, I think it may be him. Just a hunch. It’s probably wrong though.
Lee flashed after being claimed on waivers last year…in the regular season anyway. So he probably has a chance. Davis always seems to be around when I write these projections, but not sure he is any type of answer. I’ve never heard of Herron, so he will need to make some noise in camp for me to take him seriously.
Locks: Malcom Brown, Lawrence Guy, Danny Shelton
In: Adam Butler, Vincent Valentine
Way Out: John Atkins, Trent Harris
Comments: One more guy I put in the “possible trade” category is Brown. His contract is up after this season. And he may require an investment. The acquisition of Shelton could grease the skids for that…though Shelton’s contract is up after the year too. Seeing that they just made the trade to get Shelton, a trade of him seems unlikely. But maybe with the other guys around, Brown can be shopped. Again, I do not think this will happen, but I am not overlooking the possibility. Guy has his fat contract and played well enough last year I guess, so he’s in.
We had Butler as “way out” in the initial projection last year. Smart. But of course, he was someone we never heard of and he needed to catch the eye to improve his standing. And he certainly did it appears. I think with a year of development, he sticks again. Valentine missed all of last year. But if he is healthy, he stays. Because he is also young and cheap. And Bill likes his fat guys.
This years’ “never heard of dudes” in this category are Atkins and Harris. So we will follow their camp progress…or lack thereof.
Locks: Dont’a Hightower, Kyle Van Noy
In: Marquis Flowers, Elandon Roberts, Ja’Whaun Bentley
Out: Harvey Langhi, Christian Sam
Way Out: None
Comments: Once again, an absolutely putrid group here, especially if Dont’a can’t stay on the field…which is bound to happen. A stud when healthy, unfortunately, that almost is never the case. They love Van Noy and gave him a ton of dough…still trying to figure that one out. Flowers and Roberts stink, simple as that. But who else is there? And the team likes these guys too. Bentley makes my team because some of the draft picks have to make it, don’t they?? (My team has the three first and second rounders and fifth rounder Bentley making it and the five sixth and seventh rounders on the outside looking in). Sam, as a sixth rounder, may sneak on, who knows? And Langhi showed some promise last year as an undrafted free agent, made the team, played sparingly, then had that horrific car accident. Who knows how well he has recovered? If he has fully, he will get his shot, since again, this is a sad linebacking corps.
Locks: Stephon Gilmore, Eric Rowe, Jonathan Jones, Jason McCourty, Duke Dawson
Out: Cyrus Jones, Ryan Lewis, Keion Crossen, J.C. Jackson
Way Out: Jomal Wiltz
Comments: Gilmore is the clear #1 now, but who plays the other spots and in what order is anyone’s guess right now. The staff seems to like Rowe. And also Jonathan Jones, who got more time at corner as the year went on before he went down with an injury late. Some people think Jason McCourty may not be quite the lock some think he is. We’ll see, but that’s where I’m leaving him now. Dawson clearly makes it as a second round pick, but how much he plays is up for debate.
Lewis had some buzz in the spring and was on the practice squad most, if not all, of last year. But then the team signed McCourty and drafted Dawson. So much for that. Crossen was a seventh rounder and I’m not sure who Jackson or Wiltz are, so let’s leave them where they are for now.
Cyrus Jones? Interesting case. Is he worth keeping around and trying to salvage? Perhaps. He looked a little better in the preseason last year before being lost for the year with injury. But a ton better? I don’t think so. I don’t think he fumbled on returns anyway. Has Bill given up on second rounders before? Yup. Bill actually has taken several bad second round picks during his tenure. But he will get some kind of shot this summer, I will bet you that. Perhaps Cyrus or one of the others can play safety? They could also try to trade him, but what the heck are you going to get for him with how his career has gone thus far? It will be interesting to watch, since I have a feeling he may stick around.
Locks: Devin McCourty, Patrick Chung, Duron Harmon
In: Jordan Richards
Out: Damarius Travis, A.J. Moore
Way Out: Eddie Pleasant
Released: David Jones
Comments: Locks are easy…then we get to Richards. Another dude who I think is atrocious. But another dude I think the staff loves for some reason. I don’t know if one of the corners can convert to safety and knock him off. Or one of these other safety characters can do it either. Jones spent last year the practice squad and was then dumped before camp. Travis was around on the practice squad last year too, but no one is chatting him up now. Moore? No idea. I do know they signed Pleasant the other day, so that seemingly leaves him out of the mix, barring a miracle. Right now, looks like Richards will be around. Sad to say.
Locks: Stephen Gostkowski (K), Joe Cardona (LS), Matthew Slater (ST), Nate Ebner (ST), Brandon King (ST), Brandon Bolden (ST), Nicholas Grigsby (ST)
In: Ryan Allen (P)
Out: Corey Bojorquez (P), Geneo Grissom (ST)
Way Out: None
Comments: It’s amazing that with Gostkowski’s inconsistency the past few years the team has not brought someone in to at least challenge him a little bit. It just doesn’t make much sense. But with Stephen and Cardona facing no competition, they are locked in. The fact that another punter is in camp this year means Allen’s job is not safe. He probably holds the kid off, but we shall see on that.
The rest of the locks basically do not play another position, so they are listed here. And since Bill loves his core special teamers, they all stick with the exception of Grissom. But Geneo will be back. He’s a guy they can bounce on and off the roster and no one else wants him. So he will always be available. And perhaps even break camp with the squad as well.
That’s about the size of it. I’ll wait until later in camp to project the practice squad and IR/PUP/NFI and other lists. Looks like Slater, Ebner, Britt, Cyrus Jones and Jonathan Jones are starting on the preseason PUP list. Bolden is on the non-football illness list apparently as well. Some of these dudes starting on the regular season PUP list will open up roster spots for others. Let’s see how that all goes.