…now for the National League. Full disclosure: The Blowhard watches a whole helluva more American League baseball than National League. This may be quick…
Most Valuable Player:
- Kris Bryant, Chicago Cubs
- Daniel Murphy, Washington
- Anthony Rizzo, Chicago Cubs
- Nolan Arenado, Colorado
- Freddie Freeman, Atlanta
- Joey Votto, Cincinnati
- Paul Goldschmidt, Arizona
- Yoenis Cespedes, New York Mets
- Buster Posey, San Francisco
- Corey Seager, LA Dodgers
10 guys is definitely steep here, as from what I can tell it’s Bryant and then 9 other guys to fill out the ballot. Murphy 2nd? Why not? He led the league in OPS. He was 13th in WAR? Oh no!! I can’t in good conscience put Arenado at #2. Sure, his numbers are once again great. But again…Colorado. I felt like Murphs deserved to be higher than Rizzo and it feels like 2-4 is the next “tier” after Bryant.
5-7…MVP’s? I don’t know. These guys all had great years, but their teams were awful. I have friends that would probably put Freeman 2nd, since he was 3rd in both OPS and WAR and well, it doesn’t matter that his team finished 26 and a half games out of first. They also probably would put Jon Lester 3rd, since he is…Jon Lester. You know who you are.
8-10 I was just throwing darts. Even considered Wilson Ramos. Ryan Braun had some decent numbers, but…
Speaking of Lester, he may well have been worthy of a top 10 nod, along with Max Scherzer. And perhaps Madison Bumgarner. Didn’t feel it here though. If you do, I wouldn’t argue with it. Like I said, the whole list was basically a crapshoot anyway.
- Max Scherzer, Washington
- Jon Lester, Chicago Cubs
- Madison Bumgarner, San Francisco
- Johnny Cueto, San Francisco
- Kyle Hendricks, Chicago Cubs
Here’s a ballot that could use the 10 spots. Not that all of those 10 could be considered the winner of the Cy Young. But there were several others in the league that warranted “end of ballot” consideration. These include, Noah Syndergaard, Clayton Kershaw, Carlos Martinez, Jake Arrieta and the late Jose Fernandez. Perhaps Kenley Jansen and Mark Melancon too, if you like your closers. We know I don’t though.
I see this as between just Scherzer and Lester. And, of course, as a Boston homer, I would’ve loved to give this to Jon. But after going deeper into the numbers there was no way I could do it. Lester had a better ERA by about a half a run. But that’s where it ends. Max had a better WHIP by a smidge, pitched about 26 more innings, had one more win, almost 90 more strikeouts…and for those who like WAR, it was 6.2 to 5.3 in favor of Max. The competition in their divisions were similar with one playoff or near playoff team, one average team and 2 putrid ones. Plus the Cubs won their division handily and surely faced less pressure…not a major consideration, but it was all part of the equation that added up to Max.
Bumgarner and Cueto were a pretty clear next tier to me. Hendricks got the last spot largely because he led the league in ERA by a healthy margin and was 2nd in WHIP by a slim margin. Pushed him ahead of Noah for me. But I didn’t lose a ton of sleep over 5th place.
Rookie of the Year:
- Corey Seager, LA Dodgers
- Kenta Maeda, LA Dodgers
- Trea Turner, Washington
Seager was the clear-cut choice here. No other hitter played enough to qualify, while Seager played the whole year at a high level. I don’t love putting Maeda second, not after 8 years of pitching in the Japanese leagues. Yes, Japan is not the majors. But it’s probably better than Triple-A teams stateside. Either way, the rules say he is eligible for this award. Since he was also around for a full season and put up some pretty good numbers on a playoff team, he gets the runner-up position.
Third place could have gone a few ways, but I picked Turner. Showed great speed (33 steals) and good power (13 dingers) in about half a season. Throw in the high average (.342) and that sealed up third for me. Trevor Story was on his way to throwing up some monster numbers before missing the last 2 months or so with injury, but…Colorado. Aledmys Diaz also threw up decent numbers before he missed the better part of the last two months himself. And he was an All-Star, for whatever that’s worth. Seung-hwan Oh had a very nice year in relief for the Cards. After 9 years in Korea and 2 in Japan. Plus…reliever. Junior Guerra, Steven Matz, etc. There were a bunch of NL rookies who offered pretty good contributions for a half or three-quarters of a year.
Manager of the Year:
- Dusty Baker, Washington
- Joe Maddon, Chicago Cubs
- Bruce Bochy, San Francisco
Between Baker and Maddon and I hate Maddon, so gimme Baker. Nah, that’s not the reason. But it’s hard to vote for a guy that won the division by 17 and a half games and was on cruise control for pretty much the whole season. That’s what I think anyway. Sure, he had to keep the team full of All-Stars focused and all. Sometimes that can be hard (see Francona, Terry and Torre, Joe, among others). But I went with Baker for the top slot. Dusty took over for Matt Williams and guided the Nationals to 12 more wins…despite a MAJOR drop off from 2015 NL MVP Bryce Harper.
If you wanted to put Terry Collins of the Mets 3rd, that would be ok. He had to deal with many injuries, specifically in his rotation, where among all his young studs 43-year-old Bartolo Colon ended up making the most starts. The team suffered injuries in his lineup as well. And Collins still got them to the playoffs. Bochy didn’t necessarily have to deal with a boatload of injuries. But he did have to deal with a subpar everything, other than Posey, Bumgarner and Cueto. Either one works for 3rd for me.
That about sums it all up…
In honor of the Major League Baseball All-Star game selections being announced today, I present my National League All-Star picks. 21 position players, 13 pitchers, with each team represented (I don’t necessarily love this rule…but…it is the rule). (S) for starter. Comments below each position.
C: Wilson Ramos, Was (S), Buster Posey, SF, Jonathan Lucroy, Mil
Surprisingly a lot of options here, compared to the AL. Wellington Castillo and J.T. Realmuto actually earned some consideration in addition to the three I selected. Yup, I am serious. Anyway, I was tempted to once again go with Posey as the starter. But I couldn’t ignore Ramos’ superior numbers.
1B: Anthony Rizzo, CHC (S), Paul Goldschmidt, AZ, Wil Myers, SD
You can probably pretty much pencil in Rizzo and Goldy every year for the forseeable future, barring injury or change in leagues. Myers is the Padres rep, but if you’ve been paying attention, he’s had a pretty good year regardless. Last year somehow I took 6 first basemen. Three here seems about right. Brandon Belt is 12th in the NL in OPS, so maybe he has a case. Freddie Freeman isn’t awful, but also isn’t lighting the world on fire. His atrocious team does not help. I decided on someone else for the Braves rep however.
2B: Daniel Murphy, Was (S), Ben Zobrist, CHC
Murphy has carried over his performance in last year’s playoffs for the Mets right into this year. Pretty much a no-brainer here. Zobrist cost the Cubbies more than you would think this past offseason. But it’s worked out great so far. Not a lot of other candidates. Couldn’t do DJ LeMahieu here at all. Because, as you know, I penalize players a smidge for playing in Colorado. Dee Gordon is serving a PED suspension. Jean Segura? Nope.
3B: Kris Bryant, CHC (S), Matt Carpenter, StL, Nolan Arenado, Col, Jake Lamb, AZ
Did you know Carpenter leads the NL in OPS at 1.008? And that Lamb is 2nd at .974? Neither did I. I was aware that Carpenter was having a pretty good year, but shocked at seeing where Lamb stands. Bryant is 6th at .948, but he’s still my starter. One of those guys you can pencil in for multiple All-Star selections before he is done. Another monster year for Arenado, but you know…Colorado. Puts him on the team regularly, but not as a starter.
SS: Corey Seager, LAD (S), Aledmys Diaz, StL
Thin here again this year. Trevor Story has been a nice…ahem…story, but I’m not putting him at this level yet. 106 K’s so far this year. To put that in perspective, Chris Carter has 103. Yikes! Brandon Crawford deserved a look as well, but no room at the Inn for him this year. Especially when his OPS is lower than a guy like Jonathan Villar. Anyway, Seager is one of those potential stars and at 22 years old, he may be that already. Diaz came out of nowhere earlier this year and kept Jhonny Peralta’s job when Peralta came back from his injury. And he hasn’t missed a beat.
OF: Yoenis Cespedes, NYM (S), Marcell Ozuna, Mia (S), Bryce Harper, Was (S), Carlos Gonzalez, Col, Gregory Polanco, Pit, Adam Duvall, Cin, Odubel Herrera, Phi
Seven outfielders, but since no DH’s are selected in the NL, 2 or 3 of these guys could rotate in there. Another takeaway? No Giancarlo Stanton or Andrew McCutchen. I do like to try to include real “superstars” in these games, even if they are not performing to their usual standards in a specific year. The All-Star Game is really an exhibition, even though it decides home field advantage in the World Series, as foolish as this decision continues to be. Fans want to see these types of players though and that’s why the superstars get voted in regularly, regardless of current performance. Unfortunately, those guys have been less than good this year. On top of that, they may be the 3rd best option at OF on their own teams this season (Ozuna & Christian Yelich in Mia; Polanco and Starling Marte in Pit). I’m sure we haven’t heard the last of them though. Ryan Braun’s numbers are pretty good and he is 11th in OPS. But since he is a “convicted” liar and cheater, he doesn’t make my team. Ok, I am sure there are other scumbags on this team too. But that’s what I’m going with.
Moving on, Harper isn’t having the best year. But he’s the reigning MVP and putting up fairly decent numbers. See the explanation above on why he starts on my team. Gonzalez can be basically lumped in with Arenado…on the team every year, but playing in Colorado makes me never put him as a starter. Cespedes and Ozuna seem like obvious starters to me. Polanco is 5th among NL OFs in OPS. Duvall and Herrera are their teams reps. Since Jay Bruce and Joey Votto have slightly higher OPS’s than Duvall, you could argue either of them as the rep. But I’m not. Especially since Votto had a horrendous start. The only other true candidate from the Phillies was Jeanmar Gomez. No thanks.
P: Clayton Kershaw, LAD (S), Max Scherzer, Was, Jake Arrieta, CHC, Johnny Cueto, SF, Madison Bumgarner, SF, Jon Lester, CHC, Jose Fernandez, Mia, Noah Syndergaard, NYM, Stephen Strasburg, Was, Julio Teheran, Atl, Kenley Jansen, LAD, Mark Melancon, Pit, Jeurys Familia, NYM
Probably like 5 or 6 of the above named starters have a legitimate claim to start the All-Star Game, but I’m going with Kershaw. ERA is under 2.00 and of course he is his usual dominant self so far this year. But he is hurt in real life, so if I had to choose a backup starter it would have to be Arrieta. Since he is the reigning Cy Young award winner, maybe I should have picked him anyway. Cueto is 12-1, Strasburg is 10-0, etc. Lot of studs on this staff. Well, Teheran is 3-7, but since his ERA is 2.72 and the Braves are really an AAAA-level team, he is here as their rep.
There was some talent left off here too. Cases could be made for Jacob deGrom, Carlos Martinez, Kenta Maeda, the old John Lackey and the really old Bartolo Colon…if you can believe that. Toyed with Drew Pomeranz as the Padres rep. But felt like Myers was the better choice considering all the pitching options available in the NL.
The way I feel about closers, with all the options for starters, it is somewhat surprising that I didn’t go with 13 starters and no relievers. But I felt the 3 closers selected were worthy. Jansen and Melancon have ERA’s around 1.30 and Jansen, in particular, has been dominant. Familia is 29-29 in save opportunities. Speaking of dominant, it’s a little bit of a shame that Fernando Rodney got traded from San Diego to Miami…going from closer to setup man. Yes, this just happened recently, but it did impact my thinking. Rodney gave up ONE run in three months for the Padres, going 17 for 17 in saves opps in the process. Sure, he only pitched a shade under 29 innings, but impressive nonetheless. He may have been my Padres rep if he remained in SD. But no way he is Miami’s. Probably should have found a spot for him anyway. Maybe we can pretend he will be Kershaw’s injury replacement…now there’s a win-win, right?!
The only other closers I gave consideration to were A.J. Ramos and Hector Rondon. But Ramos didn’t quite do it for me. And since Theo Epstein apparently is trying to pry one of the Yankees’ three bullpen studs to presumably unseat Rondon, I dismissed him as an option. The only middle man I considered was Sadaharu Oh…ummmmm, I mean, Seung Hwan Oh of the Cards. He appears to now be their closer, with Trevor Rosenthal being awful. But the competition was too tough for him to have a realistic shot.
That about covers it…so let’s see how mine compares to the real selections…
In honor of the Major League Baseball All-Star game played Tuesday, here is my National League All-Star team. 20 position players, 14 pitchers, each team represented. (S) for starter. Comments below each position. NL team was a little harder to pick. Simply because based on the statistics, I should’ve taken 14 position players and 20 pitchers. But that of course would look foolish, so…
C: Buster Posey, SF (S), Yadier Molina, StL
As noted in the AL column, not a huge fan of taking 3 catchers. Suppose a case could have been made for Yasmani Grandal and his 14 homers over Molina. But he doesn’t have enough at-bats to qualify for the batting title, so I held that against him (did anyone realize only 4 NL catchers actually have enough at-bats to qualify? I find that interesting, though it may only be me that does. I get that a lot…). Plus, we know what Yadier is defensively.
1B: Paul Goldschmidt, AZ (S), Anthony Rizzo, CHC, Freddie Freeman, Atl, Adrian Gonzalez, LAD, Joey Votto, Cin, Adam Lind, Mil
6 first basemen you say? I say yes. For one, all 6 are in the top 11 in the NL in OPS. For two, no DH’s are to be selected in the NL, so some can play there. For three, Lind can play the outfield if you were desperate. For four, I chose Lind as the Brewer rep. So there you go.
2B: Dee Gordon, LAD (S), Joe Panik, SF
Can you believe I had Chase Utley here as a backup to Gordon last year? Wow, what a drop off for Utley this year. I don’t necessarily love Gordon, as steals are overrated a bit. But he is hitting .338 too, so…and Joe Panik? Yeah, I could’ve gone Kolten Wong here too. But what’s really the difference? I flipped a coin…actually Panik had the higher OPS, so I went with that.
3B: Todd Frazier, Cin (S), Nolan Arenado, Col, Kris Bryant, CHC
Frazier and Arenado are having monster years, but Nolan gets penalized for “The Colorado Effect”, so Todd starts. I was hesitant on Bryant at first. But the lack of offensive candidates here in general, and the excitement of showcasing the kids that could become faces of the game (you’ll see this for one more example later) led me to select him.
SS: Jhonny Peralta, StL (S), Brandon Crawford, SF
Thin, but the best of the lot unfortunately. Yup, Tulo is totally out this year for me. I went through the whole Colorado thing last year. No need to rehash that again. Bottom line: I penalize guys for putting up huge numbers because of that park. Right or wrong. Tulo’s home/road splits aren’t as pronounced as they were at this time last year. But his overall numbers didn’t do enough for me.
OF: Giancarlo Stanton, Mia (S), Andrew McCutchen, Pit (S), Bryce Harper, Was (S), Justin Upton, SD, Joc Pederson, LAD
Can’t get any more airtight than these three starters. Upton is the Padre rep and for Joc? See Bryant, Kris above. .230 isn’t awesome, but he is still in. You want AJ Pollock instead? No thanks…
P: Zack Greinke, LAD (S), Max Scherzer, Was, Gerrit Cole, Pit, Clayton Kershaw, LAD, Shelby Miller, Atl, Jacob deGrom, NYM, Jake Arrieta, CHC, Carlos Martinez, StL, AJ Burnett, Pit, Johnny Cueto, Cin, Madison Bumgarner, SF, Francisco Liriano, Pit, Cole Hamels, Phi, Aroldis Chapman, Cin
13 starters and 1 closer? Yup. Honestly, there were a whole slew of guys that I could’ve taken here. Some gaudy numbers all around the league. Of course, that’s probably because it’s the NL, but the numbers are the numbers. Anyway, Greinke doesn’t have the K’s that Max or Clayton have, but you can’t argue a 1.39 ERA. He was the right choice to start. Yes, I took 3 Pirates. Cole is 13-3, Burnett has a 2.11 ERA and Liriano has a 1.03 WHIP and is over a K per inning. Simply stated stats, but they belong.
Miller’s performance this year makes you wonder why the Cardinals gave him up. Usually the Cards know who to get rid of cuz they aren’t very good (see Kelly, Joe, Craig, Allen, Red Sox, Boston). deGrom and Hamels are their teams’ reps. Hamels numbers are inflated from a couple of shellings, but his overall numbers are decent enough. Other than Jonathan Papelbon and maybe Ken Giles, candidates were sparse on the Phils, so I went with the horse. Bumgarner’s numbers may not be quite as good as others. But he’s here for a good first half and a dominant postseason last year. Arrieta’s and Cueto’s WHIPs are both under 1.00, have nice ERAs and average about a K per inning.
Honestly could’ve made cases for John Lackey, Lance Lynn, Michael Wacha, Tyson Ross, Jason Hammel, Matt Harvey, etc. But how many starters can you take?
Chapman seemed to be the only dominant bullpen guy out there and thus he was the only one selected. There are a whole slew of closers with 20 plus saves and a 1-something ERA. Drew Storen, Jeurys Familia, Trevor Rosenthal, Mark Melancon, Francisco Rodriguez, etc. But looking at their overall numbers, I didn’t feel it. Plus, I saw Melancon pitch in the AL. Not pretty. I’ll never forget his last meaningful appearance for the BoSox (he got shipped to AAA after that game and then came back later in the year only to pitch mopup). 6 batters, 6 runs, 3 homers, all of them moonshots. The expression on his face as he gave up his last one? Complete shellshock. Happy to be back in NL I bet.
Guys like Pap and John Axford, Brad Ziegler, etc…same boat, with less saves. Kenley Jansen actually has been dominant (16 saves, 0.55 WHIP, 1.66 ERA, 2/38 BB/K ratio), but he missed half the first half and has only pitched 22 innings. Not enough. And seem to be a lot of middle men with gaudy numbers. But middle men certainly will get squeezed out here with the rest of the candidates. Ain’t no Wade Davis or Dellin Betances in this group. Maybe Kevin Siegrist. AJ Ramos? Possibly. But not this year…